RoA and NiS alt jacket

[Clara Oswald]

So my alt arrived, and it's not bad....but I'm still not that happy with it.  I'm wearing it today, and it's cold out (for North Carolina that is) and I am definately not warm enough.  On top of that, my hubby said I look like "an evil German lady" (Somebody clearly has watch too much Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, lol).  So I think I'm going to sell it.  It looks great, in fact, pretty darn close as far as the zipper and the pocket placement.  So my question for y'all, as they say here in the south, lol, is this: Which of these ebay finds should I purchase?

H&M Charcoal Denim Cropped Motorcycle Jacket Size S
This one is awesome, but has no pockets.  I could fix this, but it would take some work.  It also has a collar, but that is easily fixed.

cotton on- moto denim jacket- size S- black
This one has the correct pockets, but no zipper on the sleeves.  I might be able to fix that, but I'm not excited about doing it.  It also has a collar, but it is not an easy one to get rid of.


Urban Outfitter Bnwt Silence And Noise Denim Cropped Jacket Size S
I like this one a lot as far as looks, but it has zipper pockets. Once again, it also has a collar I would have to get rid of.  I'm also afraid the zipper might be too metallic.

I'm leaning toward the first two, but the price of the H&M jacket is up there, which is a problem, even for a "Or Best Offer."
I dunno, advice?  Or if you know of any better alts, I am definitely open to suggestions.

[madgirlinabox]

Just a heads up, the first 2 are the same jacket, the seller might be a fake, but it is definitely the best out of them. Be really careful because I think the same thing happened with my Sparkle and Fade playsuit (from CH). Hope you find an alt to suit you

[Clara Oswald]

Oh junk, the link didn't work right for the first one. I fixed it. Try it again.

[madgirlinabox]

Id say number 2 in that case